Back to Product

Sitka Sandal Reviews

David W.

Verified Buyer

Originally bought size 13 sandals,

Originally bought size 13 sandals, bit on the small side so upsized to a 14. Love the quality, know they will have no problem being put through serious use

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Aquafade · Size: 14

Apr 5, 2026

Patton S.

Verified Buyer

sitka quality you would expect :u1F90C|type_3:

very high-quality I did need to size up

Pro

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 13

Apr 5, 2026

Tyler P.

Verified Buyer

Look great

Haven’t had the chance to wear them much but the little bit I’ve worn them they feel great

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Apr 5, 2026

Michael J.

Verified Buyer

Very comfortable and seem to

Very comfortable and seem to be built well!

Military & Veterans

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Apr 3, 2026

Jason B.

Verified Buyer

Excellent

Great

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Aquafade · Size: 11

Apr 3, 2026

MATT B.

Verified Buyer

They are by far the

They are by far the best and most comfortable sandle that I have ever worn.

Pro

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: True to size

Size: 13

Apr 3, 2026

Jeffery L.

Verified Buyer

Sitka Sandal

Sandals are high quality and well constructed.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Apr 3, 2026

Gary J.

Verified Buyer

Great price

There good sandals and no doubt price was right but they definitely could be a lot more comfortable if planning on being your shoe for the day, only a few hours great!

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 14

Apr 2, 2026

Rory M.

Verified Buyer

I’m a size 9 1/2

I’m a size 9 1/2 wide and I bought a size 10. They were a little tight at first but they are pretty comfy after a couple uses.

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 10

Apr 2, 2026

Ross P.

Verified Buyer

So far so good, I

So far so good, I normally wear a 10. 5 shoe, sized up to 11 and they fit perfect, I think a 10 would be way too small

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Apr 2, 2026

Tiffany M.

Verified Buyer

Cozy and Classy

They are so cozy and classy. Sitka knocked it out of the park on this one!

Military & Veterans

Fit: True to size

Color: Sitka Black · Size: 7

Apr 2, 2026

Kyle A.

Verified Buyer

Best ever

Nice and comfortable. Would recommend to everyone

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 13

Apr 2, 2026

Harry J.

Verified Buyer

The flip flop sandals

The flip flop sandals are the most comfortable I’ve ever owned. True fit and easy to keep on your feet.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Apr 2, 2026

tucker C.

Verified Buyer

Very comfy

Very comfy

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Apr 2, 2026

Edythe M.

Verified Buyer

Great shoe

Stylish and comfy. Would recommend.

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Apr 2, 2026

Don T.

Verified Buyer

So Close. . .

Well made and durable. Love the bit of arch support. I normally wear a size 11, typically in a wide, and these are a hint too small both in length and width. Maybe with a lot of wear, they will break in more

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Coyote · Size: 11

Apr 2, 2026

James B.

Verified Buyer

Sitka Sandal

Decent sandal. Where the straps are connected to the bottom of the sandal are somewhat larger and hurt your foot.

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Apr 2, 2026

James H.

Verified Buyer

Well made, but size runs very small.

I love Sitka gear, but I’m noticing all their footwear runs very small. I am normally a 10 in all shoes, but for Sitka I need to remember to bump it up at least 1 size.

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Apr 2, 2026

Gabby G.

Verified Buyer

Super comfortable

Super comfortable. My only complaint is that they're a smidge small. My heel feels like its on the back edge of the sandal. I wear a women's 9. 5 and bought the size 8 since it runs in men's.

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 8

Apr 1, 2026

Richard M.

Verified Buyer

Great sandal

Runs very small definitely get bigger

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Apr 1, 2026

Tim S.

Verified Buyer

Great sandals

Very comfortable, they run a bit small, so order a size up

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 12

Apr 1, 2026

Mark P.

Verified Buyer

Sitka at the beach

Amazing flip flops!

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 12

Apr 1, 2026

Eric H.

Verified Buyer

Awesome! Fit great.

They fit great. Comfortable and look great.

Height: 6'3'' - 6'5'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Mar 31, 2026

Sam L.

Verified Buyer

Sitka Sandals

I’ve used Sitka hunting gear for a long time. If I’m not at work or church, I’m in sandals. These are the best sandals I’ve owned, & I’ve tried all the major brands. The material on the sole of the sandal grips and holds the surface beneath you, much like a boat shoe would. I would highly recommend getting a pair if you spend time outdoors & aren’t a fan of shoes!

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Size: 8

Mar 31, 2026

Bryce B.

Verified Buyer

Love it

I love them but unfortunately my little puppy got ahold of them and tore them up. But for the week i had them they were so comfortable!

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Mar 31, 2026

Ben L.

Verified Buyer

Feels great

Feels great might run a size small or might break in perfect. Haven’t worn them enough yet to be sure.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Mar 31, 2026

Paul O.

Verified Buyer

Summertime Work Boot Relief!

Excited to see Sitka offering flip-flops. Somewhere between an 11 and 12. Ordered 12s. Perfect. 10hrs a day in work boots. Don’t care how tough you think you are, feet need to be feet. Comfortable wide platform to guard against damage and great wet traction. Thanks again Sitka for contributing to my lifestyle with a product that works… Slides for camp next?

Military & Veterans

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Size: 12

Mar 31, 2026

John S.

Verified Buyer

Solid Flops

These are very comfortable with good support and traction.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Mar 31, 2026

Shannon G.

Verified Buyer

Runs small

I bought 3 pairs of these shoes for my 3 sons, sizes 12, 13 & 14. The son that wears a 12 had to size up to the 13. The son that wears a 13 had to size up to the 14, and the son that wears 14 was left without a pair. I will exchange the size 12s for a 15, but it's just one more step I didn't want to have to do. Nonetheless, the shoes are really comfy!

Height: 6'6'' - 6'8''

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II

Mar 30, 2026

Jerry c.

Verified Buyer

Stylish thongs

Comfy with great arch supoort

Pro

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Mar 30, 2026

Alex D.

Verified Buyer

Sandal

Good quality

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 281 lbs - 310lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Mar 30, 2026

Wyatt C.

Verified Buyer

Runs Small

Just a tad Small I'm a 12 in most other brands and that leaves me a little room for error with the heel. But these are cutting it close I would size up.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 251 lbs - 280lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Mar 30, 2026

BREE S.

Verified Buyer

Best sandals ever

Love these! Best ones I have ever had Super comfortable

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Mar 30, 2026

Noah R.

Verified Buyer

5 star

I wear a size 9 but a 10 in these

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Mar 30, 2026

George F.

Verified Buyer

Not comfortable

Not very comfortable I can feel the "ridges" in the soles.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Mar 30, 2026

Christopher J.

Verified Buyer

Fit perfect - true to

Fit perfect - true to size.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 11

Mar 29, 2026

Hunter O.

Verified Buyer

I wear size 11 1/2

I wear size 11 1/2 shoes and size 12 works perfect

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Mar 29, 2026

Gary C.

Verified Buyer

Comfortable and great looking.

Comfortable and great looking.

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Mar 28, 2026

David S.

Verified Buyer

They are very comfortable I

They are very comfortable I love wearing them. I normally wear a 10-10. 5 and I had to send my first set back and the 11's fit amazing.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 10

Mar 28, 2026

Edwin D.

Verified Buyer

My foot is a normal

My foot is a normal 10. 5 size. These fit me true to size, and I find them comfortable to wear

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Mar 27, 2026

peter e.

Verified Buyer

Odd fit

I wear a 9 in just about every shoe/boot/sandals I own, these while are slightly to narrow for me they will stretch ( I have wide feet) the edge of my heel hangs off a bit and my toes dont seem to reach far enough forward. These just seem slightly smaller than ever other size 9 shoe,boot, sandal I have ever worn.

Pro

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Mar 25, 2026

Gabriel V.

Verified Buyer

Ordered a 12 originally, unfortunately

Ordered a 12 originally, unfortunately they were small. Requested exchange for 13s and they feel and fit great.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: Runs small

Size: 13

Mar 25, 2026

Brock G.

Verified Buyer

Love these sandals! They fit

Love these sandals! They fit great. I would definitely say true to size. So get up a size if you want a good fit.

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 12

Mar 25, 2026

Mark M.

Verified Buyer

Sitka sandals

Good fit, form, and function. Should do the trick.

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 221 lbs - 250lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Mar 24, 2026

Josh F.

Verified Buyer

Good sandal

I bought a pair, liked them a lot and bought a second pair in a different color. They are really comfortable. More comfortable than most sandals. Good footbed for great support and that is why I purchased a second pair.

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Mar 24, 2026

Ethan W.

Verified Buyer

Very Comfortable & Versatile

I recently purchased two pairs. One for land and one for the water. Being a saltwater guide, I am constantly on the look for footwear that accommodates my needs. These sandals have checked all the boxes. Very comfortable, even when wet, fast drying, no annoying dye stains on your feet after being wet, and most importantly the cushioning acts as a great shock absorber which leads to a lower amount of back and knee pain when being out all day. I would highly suggest these to anyone who spends long days in sandals. Fantastic product

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Size: 12

Mar 24, 2026

Noah C.

Verified Buyer

Great fit and super comfortable

Haven’t worn flip flops in a couple years but man are these nice. Out of the box they fit perfect and are easily one of my most comfortable shoes to wear every day. I would recommend to anyone that needs a shoe they can walk around in all day and still take to the beach/lake.

Height: 5'6'' - 5'8'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Coyote · Size: 9

Mar 23, 2026

Eli K.

Verified Buyer

Good

Fit perfectly and look amazing

Height: 6' - 6'2'' · Weight: 131 lbs - 160lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Elevated II · Size: 11

Mar 23, 2026

Josh T.

Verified Buyer

Well made but uncomfortable

Seem to be well made. Straps are comfortable but the something is off with the shape of the insole. Start hurting the arches of my feet after wearing for awhile. They run a little small also.

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 161 lbs - 190lbs

Fit: Runs small

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Mar 23, 2026

Ryan H.

Verified Buyer

Comfortable

Very comfortable for a flip flop.

Height: 5'9'' - 5'11'' · Weight: 191 lbs - 220lbs

Fit: True to size

Color: Optifade Cover · Size: 10

Mar 23, 2026

Sitka Sandal Reviews | SITKA Gear